My Review of Thoroughbreds (2017)

 

Written And Directed by Cory Finley

Amanda (to Lily): "You cannot hesitate. The only thing worse than being incompetent, or being unkind, or being evil, is being indecisive."

I fancied something of a black comedy and I remember that I saw this movie late at night a few years ago. I tracked it down again and watched it to refresh my memory. Two teenage girls and one much darker than the other. 

If you've ever seen the movie Heavenly Creatures, this movie felt like it was riffing some similar plot strands. You've got rich girl Lily (Anya Taylor-Joy). She's been hired to "tutor" social outcast and emotionless Amanda (Olivia Cooke). The latter clocked this immediately.

There was a time when both Lily and Amanda were friends but drifted apart. Amanda also opened the movie by performing a mercy killing on her horse but rumours of that incident have portrayed her in a much worse light to her peers. Is Amanda truly devoid of emotions?

She's definitely convinced that she's devoid of them and she was more than happy to show Lily how to fake crying pretty well. Amanda also quickly worked out how much Lily hated her stepfather, Mark (Paul Sparks). It's not like Lily made much of an effort to conceal her hatred for him.

In fact, it was slightly comical when Lily pretended to be affronted by Amanda's suggestion of killing Mark, only to openly embrace the idea in very little time. Trying to get local drug dealer Tim (Anton Yelchin) to perform the task however turned out to be more of a challenge. He wisely opted not to get dragged into their crazy scheme. 

As for the actual murder itself, Lily being the one to get her hands dirty but frame Amanda for the deed didn't surprise me. Amanda even going along with it almost didn't phase me either. In a bittersweet way, both girls got what they wanted.

- Tim had a conviction for statutory rape and ended up as a valet in the last scene. Mark was definitely coercive controlling Lily's mother. Anton Yelchin died shortly after filming.

- Keeping with the horse theme, there's one scene where Amanda started making horse noises. She even dreamed of a world with Thoroughbreds.

- Standout music: King Harvest's Dancin' In The Moonlight and Rome Will Burn's Chameleon.

- Chronology: Set in a suburban Connecticut.

Thoroughbreds (2017) might lift from better films but it did manage to hold it's own reasonably well. Both Olivia Cooke and Anya Taylor-Joy are on solid ground with this one. A good final performance from Anton Yelchin too, I might add.

Rating: 7 out of 10